Description

    May 1775 Siege of Boston muster roll listing twenty-nine Lexington Alarm Minutemen including two African-Americans & a soldier killed at Bunker Hill.

    [Revolutionary War]. Siege of Boston Manuscript Document Listing Forty-nine Soldiers in Captain Luke Drury's Company. One page, 13.5" x 13.75", partly printed form on Britannia watermarked paper, [likely Cambridge, Massachusetts], [circa May 1775]. There are thirteen ruled columns, four of which are accomplished in manuscript by Nathan Morse: "Men's Names", "Towns whence they came", "Rank", and "Time of Inlistment". The lower margin has been extended to accommodate the last four names. The names, as they appear on the document, are shown below in italics:
    Luke Drury Cap1... April 19th 2
    Asaph Sharmon lf L,1... April 19th [Asaph Sherman] 2
    Jonas Brown 2d L,1... April 19th 2
    Nathan Morse ... Serjeant /April 26th 4
    Shelomith Stow ... Serjeant/April 19th 2
    Ebenezer Phillips ... Serjeant/April 19th 2
    Jonah Goulding ... Serjeant/April 19th 2
    William Walker ... Corporal/April 19th 2
    Joseph Leland ... Corporal/April 19th 2
    Abner Brigham [of] Cry don [Croydon, NH] / Corporal /May 20th 1
    William Moore ... Corporal/April 19th [killed August 17,1775, on expedition to Canada] 2
    Elijah Rice ... Drum.r [Drummer] /April 19th 2
    ZadockPutnam ... Fifer/April 19th 2
    EdwardButtrick ... April 2[?] 3
    Isaac Brigham 2
    Forten Burnea [Fortin/Fortune/Fortunatus Burnee; African-American] 3
    Peter Butler 2
    Esick Dexter [Esek Dexter] 3
    Zebulon Daniels 1
    William Evens [William Evans] 3
    Gad Smith [of] Gilford, in York [Guilford, ME] 1
    Solomon Stow 1
    Benjamin Grover 1
    Aaron Heath [of] Tyringham [or Alstead, NH; enlisted April 26, 1775; taken prisoner 3 times] 1
    Jonathan Hemenway [Jonathan Hemingway; of Framingham] 1
    Thadeus Kemp [of] Bilreca [Thaddeus Kemp; of Billerica; enlisted April 29, 1775] 1
    Ebenezer Leland [also of Croydon, NH] 2
    Elezar Leland [Eleazer Leland; also of Croydon, NH; enlisted May 20, 1775] 1
    Thomas Leland [Sr] [of Sutton] 5
    Thomas Leland 2d 1
    James Marting [of] Walpole, NH [enlisted April 26, 1775] 1
    Ebenezer Melendy 2
    Ebenezer Wadsworth [also of Alstead, NH; guardian of above William Evans] 1
    Samuel Heards [Samuel Heard; killed June 17,1775 at Bunker Hill] 1
    William Marting [of Chelmsford; enlisted May 1, 1775] 1
    Thomas Pratt2
    Joseph Plumly [Joseph Plumley; also of Alstead, NH] 1
    Matthias Rice 2
    Henry Redner [also of Sandisfield; enlisted May 7, 1775] 1
    George Smith 3
    Eliphalet Smith [born in Suffield, CT; of Sandisfield] 3
    Samuel Starns [Samuel Stearns] 2
    Moses Sherman 2
    Jonah Stow [of] Alstead, NH [enlisted April 26, 1775] 1
    John Banks [also of Alstead, NH] 1
    Joseph Anthony [enlisted April 29, 1775; African-American] 1
    Solomon Brooks 2
    Elisha Aldrich [enlisted April 26, 1775] 3
    Jaazaniah How [Jezaniah Howe; also of Alstead, NH; enlisted April 29, 1775] 1

    Of the forty-nine men listed on this document, at least twenty-nine were Grafton, Massachusetts-area Minutemen who had very recently responded to the Lexington-Concord Alarm April 19-21,1775, including Fortune Burnee, of African American and Native American heritage, joined by his half-brother, Joseph Anthony, who enlisted on April 29th and died in service. Revolutionary War documents listing Minutemen and black troops are scarce and desirable, but in addition, this is one of the first printed forms of the American Army, and Samuel Heard who was killed at Bunker Hill the next month, and William Moore, also killed in service that summer, are also listed. An extremely rare touchstone to the earliest days of the Revolutionary War. A little soiling with a few stains, somewhat wrinkled, professionally mended 1½" tear into names column and 2" fold separation, overall very good.


    More Information:

    Footnotes:

    [1] Not found listed on a surviving Lexington Alarm muster roll. Massachusetts Soldiers and Sailors. 20 of the 49 men, counted by us as Militiamen rather than Minutemen.

     

    [2] Captain Luke Drury's Grafton Company, marched 36 miles in response to the Lexington Alarm, April 19, 1775. Ibid, probably citing original muster roll later sold at Sotheby's Guthman Sale, December 1, 2005, lot 51. Also reprinted in History of Grafton. 20 of the 49 men. Note that Asaph Sherman's April 19th service is not shown there, but is mentioned in KS# 20993.09. In addition, KS# 20993.04 shows that he was an officer in Drury's Militia Company, May 31, 1773. Thus the total force of Drury's company that day seems to have been 47, not 46.

     

    [3] Marched 36 miles on April 21, 1775 to join Capt. Aaron Kimball's April 19th Grafton Company. Ibid. Also in History of Grafton. 7 of the 49 men.

     

    [4] Captain Aaron Kimball's Grafton Company, marched 36 miles in response to the Lexington Alarm, April 19, 1775. Ibid. Also in History of Grafton.  1 of the 49 men.

     

    [5] Captain John Putnam's Sutton Company, marched approx. 42 miles in response to the Lexington Alarm, April 19, 1775. Ibid. 1 of the 49 men.

     

    Historical Background:

    Today, the terms minuteman and militiaman are often used interchangeably, but there was a distinction during the eighteenth century. Militia were men in arms formed to protect their towns from foreign invasion. They could designate up to one quarter of their force as minutemen, a specially trained force required to be highly mobile and able to assemble instantly to a call to arms. It is very difficult to categorize specific men into either of the two groups based on the surviving historical record. We apply the term here to all of those militia who responded April 19-21, 1775, to the Lexington-Concord Alarm. Importantly though, the extant Drury April 19, 1775 muster roll, mentioned in footnote #2, seems to list his 19 [20] "Minute Men" first, with the remaining 27 out of 46 [47] men listed in a separate section. Remarkably, 15 of those 20 true "Minute Men" were still with Drury into 1776, and sign this document.

     

    In addition to the April 19, 1775 muster roll, mentioned in footnote #2, only two other rolls from that day have appeared at auction: Sotheby's Guthman Sale, December 1, 2005, lot 26 - Capt. Leonard Butterfield's Dunstable Co.; and Christie's Snider Sale, June 21, 2005, lot 61 - Sgt. David Hartwell's Concord Co.

     

    Joseph Anthony and Fortune Burnee, Jr., half brothers, were both part African-American and Hassanamisco Nipmuc (Native American). Compared to records of white New Englanders, we know relatively little about them, but even so, more information exists on these freedmen than is the norm. Several of the Anthonys and Burnees were recorded in the Grafton vital, land, and probates records [the U.S. census neglected to record Native Americans from 1790-1890], and the Burnees have been discussed in recent historical and sociological literature: exploring the relationships both amongst marginalized peoples as well as with their white Yankee neighbors in eighteenth century New England; the definitions of race and identity; social mobility; Indian and black cultures; gender roles; Anglo-Nipmuc land dealings; and the remarkable preservation and history of an 190-acre tract of land in Grafton known as Hassanamesit Woods, which is the site of a seventeenth-century "praying Indian" village with Nipmuc habitations that clung on into the mid-nineteenth century.

     

    Joseph Anthony was born in Grafton on December 24, 1753, son of Joseph/William Anthony, "Negro" and Abigail (Printer) Abraham, "Indian." According to a Nipmuc leader and genealogist, Anthony's ancestors include Hassanamisco Nipmuc Chief Anaweakin [second in command in King Philip's War in 1675-6; along with Philip/Metacom, Anaweakin was killed, and his children sold into slavery]; his father, Noas, Sachem of Hassanamesit, forced into exile at the same time and died at Deer Island in Boston Harbor; and Nanapashemet, Great Sagamore of the Massachuset Federation who was killed in battle in 1619 at Rock Hill, Medford, the year before Massachusetts was colonized by the English. In 1728, seven Indian "Planters" or householders and 33 English re-divided the land at Hassanamesit to incorporate the town of Grafton. In 1739, Abigail Printer married Andrew Abraham, Jr., "Indian Planter." Based on Abigail Printer's surname, and the very small population left at Hassanamesit in the 1700s, it is believed that she is a descendant of Rev. John Eliot's notable contemporary James Printer, a Harvard student in 1645-46, who worked for Samuel Green, printing Eliot's famous "Indian Bible" in 1663. Abigail and Andrew had three sons, before he died in August 1746, after returning from service in the Port Royal Campaign. Abigail married second, November 14, 1752, Joseph/William Anthony. Little is known of him, other than his listing in town records as a "Negro." It appears he died circa 1756. Their son, the signer of this document, Joseph Anthony, married Lydia Mercy (Johnson). He enlisted in the army April 29, 1775, and was reported missing July 6, 1777 [probably at the Battle of Ticonderoga], and dead December 26, 1777 [possibly a prisoner of war on board an infamous New York City British prison ship]. At the time, he was a private in Capt. Blanchard's Company of Col. James Wesson's 9th Massachusetts Regiment.

     

    Fortune Burnee, Jr. [Grafton records spell his name a number of different ways.] Dr. David R. Mandell believes there was one man of that name, but we find that Electa Kane Tritsch's postulation that there was a father and a son of the same name makes more sense. Abigail, again a widow, married a third time, January 27, 1757, to Fortune Burnee, [Sr.], described as "Negro," a veteran of one or more expeditions to Canada during the French and Indian War and widower of another Hassanamisco, Sarah (Muckamaug) Whipple. [Mandell writes that Burnee had changed his first name from William to Fortune, based on his good luck, but does not cite the source or anecdote: Fortune seems more likely a given slave name. He also claims that Burnee abandoned his first wife Sarah before her death, but Tritsch has found no evidence for this: that statement may have been compounded with Sarah's first husband, Aaron Whipple, of Providence, Rhode Island]. It is thought that Burnee Sr. died about 1771. If so, his son Fortune Burnee, Jr., is the man who served under Capt. Luke Drury. It is as yet unknown if he is the son of Fortune Burnee, Sr.'s second wife Abigail (Printer) Abraham Anthony Burnee, who died in 1776, or his first wife, Sarah (Muckamaug) Whipple Burnee, who died in 1751 [thus, he is either Anthony's younger half-brother, or older step-brother]. It is interesting to observe that Burnee signs this document with a mark, while Anthony is capable of signing in full - whether that hints that Anthony was the younger brother, with less responsibilities on the homestead, and more opportunity for education, is mere speculation. However, Tritsch (probably by process of elimination, finding that Fortune Burnee, Jr. does not appear in Sarah's estate papers) assigns him as the younger, a son of Abigail, and half-brother of Joseph Anthony. Fortune Burnee, Jr. marched on April 21, 1775 in response to the Lexington-Concord Alarm. Marriage records then show that Fortune Burnee, [Jr.] married July 31, 1778, "Phylis.. .negro servant of Rev. Mr. Frost.. .of Mendon [both are listed as "Negroes"], and then November 8, 1781, Sarah Hector, of Sutton [again, both are listed as "Negroes"]. He died in 1795.

     

    Without going into the complex history of Hassanamesit and the Hassanimisco praying Indians, Reverend Ezra Stiles's 1761 impressions of the settlement are notable: "At Grafton...! saw the Burying place & Graves of 60 or more Indians. Now not a Male Ind. in Town, & perh. 5 Squaws who marry Negroes." By 1770, the town selectmen reported "that there is but one male Indian left" - this man was in fact one of Sarah (Muckamaug) Whipple's bi-racial children, Joseph Aaron. 87 years earlier, in 1674, Daniel Gookin, had noted that the Indian village had contained twelve families (perhaps sixty souls) - King Philip's War of 1675-76 and its lingering years of conflict played a major part in this population displacement and decrease.

     

    African Americans (& Native Americans) in the American Revolution. Of the estimated 100,000 men who served in the Continental Army, at least 5,000 were black. Most black soldiers fought in integrated units, as in Massachusetts; some states, like Rhode Island had segregated regiments, while Connecticut seems to have had both segregated and integrated. Both enslaved and free African-Americans served in the army as soldiers, laborers, and servants. In some cases, slaves were offered freedom for their services as soldiers, though others remained enslaved, fighting in place of their masters. Many states had been reluctant to arm the black population, but had no other countermove to the British Lord Dunmore's offer of freedom to Southern black enlistees. A significant number of colonial blacks at this time were also partly of Native American ancestry - to take once state, Massachusetts's eighteenth-century Indian population had two females to one male, while the majority of the imported African slave laborers were male. Those figures, coupled with their removal to neighboring outskirts of colonial society, as well as the enslavement of many Indians in New England after King Philip's War, did much to comingle the two ethnic groups.

     

    Luke Drury (1734-1811) of Grafton, Massachusetts joined the militia in 1757 during the French and Indian Wars. As captain of a company of Minutemen and Militamen, he responded to the Lexington Alarm, and later joined Colonel Jonathan Ward's regiment to fight at Bunker Hill. Drury and his men served in different areas during the war, from West Point to Grafton, where his company guarded military stores. He also supported the Continentals financially, at one point giving £50 fifty pounds to enlist soldiers in Grafton. In 1786-1787, Drury became deeply involved in Shays' Rebellion, a tax revolt led by farmers in western Massachusetts. The uprising was quashed, and Drury imprisoned as "a person dangerous to the state." He was eventually released on good behavior. Drury remained active in state and local politics, serving terms as constable, deputy sheriff, tax collector, assessor, selectman, and state legislator.

     

    References:

    -Bunker Hill Monument Association. Proceedings of the Bunker Hill Monument Association, at the Annual Meeting, June 17, 1907. Boston: The Association, 1907.

    -Doughton, Thomas. "Eighteenth Century Indian Veterans: Example." Citizenship, Property, Identity & Representation: the HistoricalJourney of Southern New England's Native Peoples.

    -Kaplan, Sidney & Emma Nogrady Kaplan. The Black Presence in the Era of the American Revolution. Revised edition, University of Massachusetts Press, 1989.

    -Mandell, David R. Behind the Frontier: Indians in Eighteenth-Century Eastern Massachusetts. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1996.

    -Mandell, David R. "The Saga of Sarah Muckamugg, Indian and African American Intermarriage in Colonial New England." In Hodes, Martha ed. Sex, Love, Race, Crossing Boundaries in North American History. New York University Press, 1999.

    -Massachusetts Soldiers and Sailors in the War of the Revolution. Vols. I-XVII. Boston, 1896.

    -Pierce, Frederick Clifton. History of Grafton, Worcester County, Massachusetts... 1879.

    -Quarles, Benjamin. The Negro in the American Revolution. University of North Carolina Press, 1996.

    -Revolutionary War service records, www.footnote.com

    -Rice, Franklin P.  Vital Records of Grafton, Massachusetts, To the end of the year 1849. Worcester, 1906.

    -Silva, Chief Peter "Silver Arrow" Silva. 2002 Affidavit, Hassanamisco Reservation Foundation.

    -Stilwell, DeWitt. A Genealogical Record of One Branch of the Heath... Families. 1905.

    -Szasz, Margaret Connell. Indian Education in the American Colonies, 1607-1783.

    -Tritsch, Electa Kane. Documenting Hassanamesit Woods, Its History and Cultural Resources. Prepared for the Town of Grafton, Hassanamesit Woods Management Committee, Nov. 2006.

    -Turner, Jacob. Genealogy of the Descendants of Humphrey Turner. Boston: 1852. pp. 59-60.



    Fees, Shipping, and Handling Description: Books & Catalogs (view shipping information)

    Sales Tax information  |  Terms and Conditions

    Bidding Guidelines and Bid Increments

    Glossary of Terms

    Auction Info

    Auction Dates
    February, 2010
    11th-12th Thursday-Friday
    Bids + Registered Phone Bidders: 0
    Lot Tracking Activity: N/A
    Page Views: 2,381

    Buyer's Premium per Lot:
    19.5% of the successful bid (minimum $14) per lot.

    Sold for: Sign-in or Join (free & quick)

    Heritage membership

    Join Now - It's Free

    VIEW BENEFITS
    1. Past Auction Values (prices, photos, full descriptions, etc.)
    2. Bid online
    3. Free Collector newsletter
    4. Want List with instant e-mail notifications
    5. Reduced auction commissions when you resell your
      winnings 
    Consign now
    • Cash Advances
    • More Bidders
    • Trusted Experts
    • Over 200,000 Satisfied Consignors Since 1976
    Only 28 days left to consign to the 2017 December 10 Civil War & Militaria Arms & Armor Signature Auction - Dallas!

    Learn about consigning with us

    I have done volume business with you and never regretted it.
    J.K.,
    Redford, MI
    View More Testimonials

    HA.com receives more traffic than any other auction house website. (Source: Similarweb.com)

    Video tutorial

    Getting the most out of search

    Recent auctions

    2017 September 14 Rare Books Signature Auction - Dallas
    2017 September 14 Rare Books Signature Auction - Dallas
    REALIZED SO FAR $1,880,126