Peak season notice: Shipping for this category may take 14–21 business days after cleared payment. Thanks for your patience.
LOT #42071 |
Starting Bid: $10,000
John Adams Autograph Letter Signed...
Click the image to load the highest resolution version.
Description
John Adams Challenges New Hampshire Amid Rising Secession Crisis on the Eve of the Hartford Convention: "Are the People...prepared, ready and willing to second our Massachusetts Legislature in the great and bold atchievements [sic] which they appear to have in Contemplation?"
John Adams Autograph Letter Signed ("John Adams")
with franking signature. One page with separate address leaf and
free frank, 7 3/4 x 9 7/8 inches; Quincy; October 27, 1814.
Addressed to Governor William Plumer of New Hampshire, with three
pages of Plumer's signed autograph draft reply (dated November 25,
1814) on the verso of Adams' letter and both sides of the address
leaf.On July 12, 1814, the former governor sent Adams a copy of his Address to the Clergy of New-England, on their Opposition to the Rulers of the United States, requesting his opinion both on its message as well as Adams' thoughts on "the state of our public affairs." The pamphlet addressed the opposition of New England's Congregational and Presbyterian clergy to the government's war efforts. Although Plumer was a democratic-republican at the time of this letter, he had previously belonged to the Federalist Party for decades and switched parties only in 1808. As New England had long been predominately Federalist, this placed him in the rather unique position to comment on the resentment growing in New England amongst the party, wearied from Madison's War of 1812 and the crippling effect it had on their fishing industry and foreign commerce. The situation came to a head on October 18, 1814 when the Massachusetts legislature issued a call to the other New England states for a conference in Hartford, Connecticut with a view towards secession. Here, Adams responds to the pamphlet, in a passionate, verbose style, before closing with a pointed question about New Hampshire's intentions toward the conference. John Adams writes, in part:
"I thank you for your pamphlet... It is written with admirable temper, and carries demonstration with it, to every mind that is not rendered by party prejudice and passion, insensible to evidence. Too many of our Clergy are going the Way of the Magi, the Druids, the Mandarines, the Mufti, the Brahmins, the Pontiffs of antient and modern times; by making themselves the willing instruments of an ignorant popularity an insolent Oligarchy, or a tyrannical foreign Power. I have heared [sic] some of the grossest Newspaper Slanders trumpeted from the Pulpit; against the most important men in the Nation: and I have heared a Philipii against myself as ardent and virulent as any of Cicero against Cataline or Anthony or Vorres in a most Solemn and fervent prayer to all mighty God, deliv[er]ed on the Sabbath before a numerous Congregation, in the Seat of one of our most respectable Universitys [sic]... Upon public affairs I cannot write. Let me nevertheless ask one question: Are the People of New Hampshire, prepared, ready and willing to second our Massachusetts Legislature in the great and bold atchievements [sic] which they appear to have in Contemplation?" Signed in full, "John Adams". Address leaf franked "J. Adams".
Plumer pens a lengthy draft of his reply to Adams on the remaining three pages, which offer a fascinating, unique insight into the increasingly volatile political situation in New Hampshire. He writes, in part: "You ask my opinion whether New Hampshire is prepared to adopt the measures of the Massachusetts legislature? I think they are not. Though the damning doctrine of dismemberment has advocates here, yet I do not believe they can obtain a majority of the people, or of their Representatives, to avow it... How far these covert proceedings, aided by the taxes & measures indispensably necessary to carry on the war, may eventually influence our people in aid of their nefarious project, time only can disclose. I cannot however believe, that New England is yet so destitute of political wisdom & love of country, as to adopt a measure so fatal not only to the prosperity but to her existence as a free people... If we are worthy of the blessings of a free govt.-if we possess the temper & virtue of freemen, I cannot but think a spirit will soon pervade the people which will hurl these modern Jeroboams who have not the ambition suited to govern a whole people, into that obscurity they so richly merit..."
Plumer's final line proved surprisingly prophetic, although probably not in the way Plumer expected. The convention was held from December 15, 1814 to January 5, 1815; it adopted a strong states' rights position and proposed constitutional amendments that would redress what the New Englanders considered the unfair advantage given the South under the U.S. Constitution. Unfortunately for the Federalists, the news of the Treaty of Ghent ending the war and of General Andrew Jackson's victory at New Orleans arrived at about the same time as the conclusion of the Hartford Convention. Because the meetings were secret, the rumors that it was a secessionist convention irreparably damaged the reputation of the Federalist Party. Many called it treason. In the presidential election of 1816, the Federalists only won Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Delaware, losing the other 34 states to the Democratic-Republicans and James Monroe. It was their last presidential campaign, and shortly thereafter, the Federalist Party dissolved.
Condition: Very good overall. Appears to have originally been a bifolium, but has since cleanly separated. Evidence of expert professional restoration to a long tear along the center of the first leaf; small separation in the lower third affecting a few letters. Address leaf has been window mounted with restoration to paper loss caused by seal removal upon opening. Numerated at upper margins, presumably in Plumer's hand. Upper right corner of first leaf absent.
References: National Archives, "To John Adams from William Plumer, 12 July 1814", Founders Online.
Auction Info
2026 June 19 The John H. Freund Americana Collection Signature® Auction #6331 (go to Auction Home page)
Proxy Bidding Ends
June
19th
Friday
10:50 am CT
Auction Dates
June
19th
Friday
Proxy Bidding Time Remaining
26 Days
13h 54m 27s
Bids + Registered Phone Bidders: 0
Lot Tracking Activity: 3
Page Views: 11
Buyer's Premium per Lot:
25% of the successful bid (minimum $49) per lot.
This lot is in: 1 -
Signature® Floor Session (Live Floor, Live Phone, Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live):
(Lots 42001-42298) - 11:00 AM Central Time, Friday, June 19, 2026.
[Proxy bidding ends ten minutes prior to the session start time. Live Proxy bidding on Heritage Live now starts within 2 hours of when the auction opens for proxy bidding and continues through the live session.]
Exhibition Viewing Times, Title Page, Floor Session and License Information
Additional Location Info:
Heritage Auctions - Dallas
2801 W. Airport Freeway
Dallas, TX 75261
Shipping, Taxes, Terms and Bidding
Terms and Conditions | Bidding Guidelines and Bid Increments | Glossary of Terms
Important information concerning Sales Tax and Resale Certificates. Learn More
Terms and Conditions | Bidding Guidelines and Bid Increments | Glossary of Terms