Skip to main content
Go to accessibility notice

    Description

    Rose O'Neal Greenhow Letter to Secretary of State William H. Seward: "You may subject me to harsher, ruder treatment than I have already received, but you cannot imprison the soul."

    Rose O'Neal Greenhow Autograph Letter Signed. Eight pages, recto and verso of two bifolia, 6.25" x 7.75" (sight), Washington; November 18, 1861. An earlier description by The War Between the States auction house says it is the original, extraordinary letter published by The Richmond Whig, but we were unable to verify this . The subsequent publication of this letter caused significant embarrassment for the Lincoln administration and sent shockwaves through Washington society. It is addressed to Secretary of State William H. Seward on mourning stationery and reads in part:

    "For nearly three months I have been confined a close prisoner, shut out from air and exercise, and denied all communion with family and friends - Patience is said to be a great virtue and I have practiced it to my utmost capacity of endurance...

    On Friday August 23rd without Warrant or other show of authority I was arrested by the detective Police and my house taken in charge by them. That all my private letters and papers of a life time were read and examined by them. That every law of decency was violated in the search of my house and person, and by the surveillance over me.

    We read in History that the poor Marie Antonette had a paper torn from her bosom by lawless hands, and that even a change of linen had to be effect in sight of her brutal captors. It is my sad experience to record even more revolting outrage than that, for during the first days of my imprisonment, what ever necessity forced me to seek my chamber a detective stood sentinel at the open door. And that for a period of seven days I with my little child was placed absolutely at the mercy of men without character or responsibility. That during the first evening a portion of these men became brutally drunk, and boasted in my hearing of the "nice times" they expected with the female prisoners...

    Freedom of speach [sic] and of opinions is the birthright of Americans guaranteed to us by our Charter of liberty and Constitution of the U States. I have exercised my prerogative, and have openly avowed my sentiments. During the political struggle I opposed your Republican party with every instinct of self preservation. I believe your success a virtual nullification of the Constitution...Here I am a prisoner in sight of the Executive Mansion, in sight of the Capital...every right pertaining to the citizen has been suspended by what, I suppose the President calls a 'military necessity.' A blow has been struck by this total disregard of civil rights...

    ...You have the power, sir, and may still further abuse it. You may prostrate the physical strength, by confinement in close rooms and insufficient food--you may subject me to harsher, ruder treatment than I have already received, but you cannot imprison the soul. Every cause worthy of success has had its martyrs...My sufferings will afford a significant lesson to the women of the South, that sex or condition is no bulwark against the surging billows of the "irrepressible conflict."

    The "iron heel of power" may keep down, but it cannot crush out, the spirit of resistance in a people armed for the defence of their rights; and I tell you now, sir, that you are standing over a crater, where smothered fires in a moment may burst forth.

    It is your boast, that thirty-three bristling fortifications now surround Washington. The fortifications of Paris did not protect Louis Phillippe when his hour had come." Signed, "Rose ON Greenhow."

    Rose O'Neal Greenhow (1813-1864) was the Confederacy's most famous female spy. She is perhaps best described by the typed testimonial affixed to the frame under the auspicious title Rebel Rose Retaliates: "Washington socialite and widow of prominent Dr. Richard Greenhow, Rose O'Neal Greenhow made a career of being a confidante to Washington's rich and powerful. So when rumblings of the Civil War occurred before Fort Sumter, this Washington belle committed herself to the Confederate cause. She was known to graciously entertain in her home and pass the information gleaned from her personal associations on to her Confederate sources, ultimately to General P.G.T. Beauregard. She is credited with providing Richmond and Generals Beauregard and Joseph E. Johnston with the intelligence that spelled victory for the Confederacy at the first Battle of Bull Run in July of 1861.

    Mrs. Greenhow was under the surveillance of Allan J. Pinkerton in the summer of 1861. Pinkerton was president Abraham Lincoln's security and helped form the Secret Service during the war. On August 23, 1861, Mrs. Greenhow was arrested in her home by Union officials and became prisoner there. As the weeks passed, other female prisoners were placed in Mrs. Greenhow's home, which came to be known as "Fort Greenhow." Although quarantined and under guard, Mrs. Greenhow was still successful in smuggling messages to Confederate sources. She even used her young daughter Rose for these purposes until she was discovered.

    Three months into her incarceration, Rose Greenhow wrote duplicate letters to her former friend, Secretary of State William H. Seward. One was received by the Secretary and this, the other, was smuggled to the Richmond Whig newspaper where it was published and then reprinted in the New York Herald. The letter's publication embarrassed the Lincoln administration. In January of 1862, Rose O'Neal Greenhow was transferred with her daughter Rose to Old Capitol Prison. By then, the Northern press was calling the widow "Rebel Rose." In June she was exiled to the Confederacy in exchange for her promise not to return to the North for the duration of the war. Taking her daughter with her, she became an unofficial Confederate agent in England in 1863 and 1864. After sending her daughter to a convent school in Paris, Rose planned to return to the South and booked passage on the Condor, a light low-lying ship whose destination was Wilmington, North Carolina. It is suspected that she was carrying an important message from the British government to Confederate President Jefferson Davis. The Union navy had blockaded Southern ports and the Condor was grounded near Fort Fisher, North Carolina. To avoid capture, Rose tried to escape with $2,000 in gold and her secret dispatches in a small boat. The boat capsized and on October 1, 1864, Confederate spy Rose O'Neal Greenhow drowned; her body was washed ashore. She was given full military honors at her funeral."

    A carte-de-visite of Greenhow and her daughter, little Rose, measures 2.5" x 4" (sight), taken while she was imprisoned in Old Capitol Prison, is included in the frame. It was taken by Alexander Gardner and was published in 1862 by Matthew Brady. It would later appear in Brady's series, Incidents of War.

    The letter, CDV, typed transcription and two informational plaques are matted and framed to an overall size of 40.25" x 30.5". The letter features a double-glazed, hinged panel to allow for viewing of both sides.

    Condition: Letter has been silked for preservation. Smoothed mail folds. The frame has some light scratches and dings. Two of the decorative leaf trimmings are detached, though one is extant with the lot.


    More Information: "Washington, Nov. 18th, 1861,
    398 16th Street.
    Honbl. Wm. H. Seward,
    Sec of State:
    Sir –

    For nearly three months I have been confined, a close prisoner, shut out from air and exercise, and denied all communication with family and friends. - Patience is said to be a great virtue and I have practised it to my utmost Capacity of endurance.

    I am told Sir that upon your ipse dixit, the fate of citizens depend, and that the sign manual of the ministers of Louis the Fourteenth and fifteenth was not more potential in their day, than that of the Sec of State in 1861.

    I therefore most respectfully submit, - That on Friday, August 23rd, without Warrant or other show of authority I was arrested by the detective Police, and my house taken in charge by them; that all my private letters, and my papers of a life time, were read and examined by them. That all my private letters and papers of a life time were read and examined by them. That every law of decency was violated in the search of my house and person, and the surveillance over me.

    We read in history, that the poor Maria Antonette had a paper torn from her bosom by lawless hands, and that even a change of linen had to be effected in sight of her brutal captors. It is my sad experience to record even more revolting outrages than that, for during the first days of my imprisonment, whatever necessity forced me to seek my chamber, a detective stood sentinal at the open door. And that for a period of seven days I with my little child was placed absolutely at the mercy of men without character or responsibility. That during the first evening a portion of these men became brutally drunk, and boasted in my hearing of the "nice times" they expected to have with the female prisoners. And that rude violence was used towards a colored Servant girl during that evening; the extent of which I have not been able to learn - For any show of decoram afterwards was practiced toward me, I was indebted to the detective called Capt. Dennis.

    In the careful analysis of my papers, I deny the existance of a line I had not a perfect right to have written, or to have received - Freedom of speech and of opinion is the birth right of Americans, guaranteed to us by our Charter of liberty, the Constitution of the U States. I have exercised my prerogative, and have openly avowed my sentiments. During the political struggle, I opposed your Republican party with every instinct of self preservation. I believed your success a virtual nulification of the Constitution, and that it would entail upon us the driful consequences which have ensued. These sentiments have doubtless been found recorded among my papers, and I hold them as rather a proud record of my Legacity.

    I must be permitted to quote from a letter of yours, in regard to Russell of the London Times, which you conclude with these admirable words: "Individual errors of opinion may be tolerated, as long as good sense is left to combat them." By way of illustrating theory and practice - Here am I a prisoner in sight of the Executive Mansion, in sight of the Capital, where the proud statesmen of our land have sung their paeans, to the blessings of our free institutions. Comment is idle. Freedom of speech freedom thought - every right pertaining to the citizen has been suspended by what, I suppose, the President calls a "military necessity." A blow has been struck, by this total disregard of all civil rights against the present system of Government far greater in its effects than the severance of the Southern States. Our people have been taught to unturn the Supremacy of the law, to which all have hitherto bowed; and to look to the military power for protection against its decrees. A military spirit has been developed, which will only be subordinate to a military Dictatorship. Read history carefully, and you will find that the causes, which bring about a Revolution rarely predominate at its close, and no people have ever returned to the point from which they started - Even should the Southern State be subjugated, and forced back into the Union (which I look upon as impossible, with a full knowledge of their resources,) a different form of Government will be found needful to meet the new developments of National character. There is no class of society, no branch of industry, which this change has not reached, and the dull plodding methodical habits of the poor can never be resumed.

    My own convictions are that the only chance of our ever again being one people is in the capacity of the South to maintance herself. Then negoations can be entered into for adjustment which can bind us together stronger than ever. – Not as a conqueror or conquered But as brothers who have quarreled and are willing each to yield something for the b(l)essings of fraternal intercourse once more.

    You have held me Sir to a mans accountability, and I therefore claim the right to speak on subjects usually considered beyond a womans ken, and which you may class as "errors of opinion"- I offer no excuse for this long digression, as a three months imprisonment without formula of law gives me authority for occupying even the precious moments of a Sec of State.

    My object is to call your attention to the fact, that during this long period of my imprisonment I am yet ignorant of the causes of my arrest - That my house has been seized by the Government and converted into a prison - That the valuable furniture it contained has been abused and destroyed - That during some periods of my imprisonment I have suffered greatly for want of proper and sufficient food. Also I have to complain that more recently a woman of bad character recognized as having been seen on the Streets of Chicago as such, by several of the guard Calling herself Mrs. Onderdunk was placed here in my house, in a room adjoining mine.

    In making this exposition I have no object of appeal to your sympathies. If the justice of my complaint with a decent regard for the divers opinion does not move you, I should but waist time to claim your attention on any other lure.

    I may however recall to your mind, that but a little while since, you were quite as much prescribed by public sentiment here for the opinions and principles you held, as I am now for mine.

    I could have easily escaped arrest having had timely warning - I thought it possible that your statesmanship might prevent such a proclamation of weakness to the world, as even the fragment of a once great government, turning its arms against the breasts of women and children. - You have the power Sir and may still further abuse it. You may prostrate the phisical strength by confinement in close rooms and insufficient food. You may subject me to harsher ruder treatment than I have already received. But you cannot imprison the soul. Every cause worthy of success has had its Martyrs. The words of the Heroine Cordet are applicable here: "C'est le crime qui fait la honte, et non pas l'echafaud." My sufferings will afford a significant lesson to the women of the South - that sex or condition is no bulwark against the surging billows of the "irrepressible conflict."

    The "iron heel of power" m(a)y keep down, But it cannot crush out, the spirit of resistance in a people armed for the defence of their rights. And I tell you now Sir that you stand in the mouth of a crater where smothered fires in a moment may burst forth.

    It is your boast that thirty three Artillery fortifications now surround Washington. - The fortifications of Paris did not protect Louis Phillippe when his hour had come.

    In conclusion, I respectfully ask your attention to this protest my protest and have the honor to be &&&

    Rose O. N. Greenhow"


    Auction Info

    Auction Dates
    May, 2021
    19th Wednesday
    Bids + Registered Phone Bidders: 5
    Lot Tracking Activity: N/A
    Page Views: 888

    Buyer's Premium per Lot:
    25% on the first $300,000 (minimum $49), plus 20% of any amount between $300,000 and $3,000,000, plus 12.5% of any amount over $3,000,000 per lot.

    Sold on May 19, 2021 for: Sign-in or Join (free & quick)
    Track Item

    Heritage membership

    Join Now - It's Free

    VIEW BENEFITS
    1. Past Auction Values (prices, photos, full descriptions, etc.)
    2. Bid online
    3. Free Collector newsletter
    4. Want List with instant e-mail notifications
    5. Reduced auction commissions when you resell your
      winnings 
    Consign now
    • Cash Advances
    • More Bidders
    • Trusted Experts
    • Over 200,000 Satisfied Consignors Since 1976
    Consign to the 2021 December 5 Holiday Luxury Accessories Signature Auction .

    Learn about consigning with us

    This was my first time dealing with an auction house, and I am 100% completely impressed with Heritage. There is not an aspect of this process that I have a critique for.
    Darryl S.,
    Stuart, FL
    View More Testimonials

    HA.com receives more traffic than any other auction house website. (Source: Similarweb.com)

    Video tutorial

    Getting the most out of search